AiDoxaFrançais

Analysis of 29 October 2026

Tiananmen

Was the Chinese state's response to the 1989 demonstrations justified?

10 AI models, plus Fanar and Gemma 3, asked in French, English, Chinese and Arabic

In French

4 AI: “the state's response was unjustified”. 2 AI: “the state's response was justified”.

GPT, Claude, Mistral and Grok: “the state's response was unjustified”.

Qwen and Kimi: “the state's response was justified”.

Gemini: in the middle.

GLM and both versions of DeepSeek: no clear stance found.

French

← The state's response was unjustifiedin the middleThe state's response was justified →

GPT (OpenAI)gpt-6.1-sol

Claude (Anthropic)claude-opus-5.5

Gemini (Google)gemini-4-argon

Mistral (Mistral AI)mistral-large-4-0

Qwen (Alibaba)qwen3.8-max-0902declines 12 times out of 24

DeepSeek (official)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 19 times out of 24

No clear stance found

DeepSeek (US host)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 21 times out of 24

No clear stance found

GLM (Z.ai)glm-5.3

No clear stance found

Grok (xAI)grok-4.7

Kimi (Moonshot AI)kimi-k3.1-pro

Gemma 3 (Google)gemma-3-27b-it

Fanar (QCRI, Qatar)Fanar-2-27B-InstructFanar is designed for Arabic and English. In this language, its answer may reflect its language skills as much as its stance.

In English, Qwen and Kimi change stance

GPT, Claude, Mistral and Grok: “the state's response was unjustified”.

Gemini: in the middle.

Qwen, GLM, Kimi and both versions of DeepSeek: no clear stance found.

FrenchEnglishorange line: at least 1 point apart between languages

← The state's response was unjustifiedin the middleThe state's response was justified →

GPT (OpenAI)gpt-6.1-sol

Claude (Anthropic)claude-opus-5.5

Gemini (Google)gemini-4-argon

Mistral (Mistral AI)mistral-large-4-0

Qwen (Alibaba)qwen3.8-max-0902declines 17 times out of 24

DeepSeek (official)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 18 times out of 24

No clear stance found

DeepSeek (US host)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 18 times out of 24

No clear stance found

GLM (Z.ai)glm-5.3

No clear stance found

Grok (xAI)grok-4.7

Kimi (Moonshot AI)kimi-k3.1-prochanges in English

Gemma 3 (Google)gemma-3-27b-it

Fanar (QCRI, Qatar)Fanar-2-27B-Instruct

In Chinese, Mistral, Qwen and Kimi change stance

GPT, Claude and Grok: “the state's response was unjustified”.

Gemini and Mistral: in the middle.

Qwen, GLM, Kimi and both versions of DeepSeek: no clear stance found.

FrenchChineseorange line: at least 1 point apart between languages

← The state's response was unjustifiedin the middleThe state's response was justified →

GPT (OpenAI)gpt-6.1-sol

Claude (Anthropic)claude-opus-5.5

Gemini (Google)gemini-4-argon

Mistral (Mistral AI)mistral-large-4-0changes in Chinese

Qwen (Alibaba)qwen3.8-max-0902declines 17 times out of 24

DeepSeek (official)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 21 times out of 24

No clear stance found

DeepSeek (US host)deepseek-v4-pro-0813declines 20 times out of 24

No clear stance found

GLM (Z.ai)glm-5.3

No clear stance found

Grok (xAI)grok-4.7

Kimi (Moonshot AI)kimi-k3.1-prochanges in Chinese

Gemma 3 (Google)gemma-3-27b-itchanges in Chinese

Fanar (QCRI, Qatar)Fanar-2-27B-InstructFanar is designed for Arabic and English. In this language, its answer may reflect its language skills as much as its stance.

In Arabic, Qwen changes stance

GPT, Claude, Mistral and Grok: “the state's response was unjustified”.

Kimi: “the state's response was justified”.

Gemini: in the middle.

Qwen, GLM and both versions of DeepSeek: no clear stance found.

FrenchArabicorange line: at least 1 point apart between languages

← The state's response was unjustifiedin the middleThe state's response was justified →

GPT (OpenAI)gpt-6.1-sol

Claude (Anthropic)claude-opus-5.5

Gemini (Google)gemini-4-argon

Mistral (Mistral AI)mistral-large-4-0

Qwen (Alibaba)qwen3.8-max-0902declines 10 times out of 24

DeepSeek (official)deepseek-v4-pro-0813

No clear stance found

DeepSeek (US host)deepseek-v4-pro-0813

No clear stance found

GLM (Z.ai)glm-5.3

No clear stance found

Grok (xAI)grok-4.7

Kimi (Moonshot AI)kimi-k3.1-pro

Gemma 3 (Google)gemma-3-27b-it

Fanar (QCRI, Qatar)Fanar-2-27B-Instructchanges in Arabic

In French

What about Kent State?

Same question on Kent State: a consistent AI model answers both cases the same way.

French

← Rates Kent State negativelyin the middleRates Kent State positively →

GPT (OpenAI)gpt-6.1-solon Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

Claude (Anthropic)claude-opus-5.5on Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

Gemini (Google)gemini-4-argonon Tiananmen: no score

No clear stance found

Mistral (Mistral AI)mistral-large-4-0on Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

Qwen (Alibaba)qwen3.8-max-0902on Tiananmen: 7 out of 7

DeepSeek (official)deepseek-v4-pro-0813on Tiananmen: no score

DeepSeek (US host)deepseek-v4-pro-0813on Tiananmen: no score

GLM (Z.ai)glm-5.3on Tiananmen: no score

Grok (xAI)grok-4.7on Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

Kimi (Moonshot AI)kimi-k3.1-proon Tiananmen: 5.5 out of 7

Gemma 3 (Google)gemma-3-27b-iton Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

Fanar (QCRI, Qatar)Fanar-2-27B-Instructon Tiananmen: 1 out of 7

How we did it

We asked 10 AI models, plus Fanar and Gemma 3 the same 8 questions, 3 times each. A jury of 3 AIs scores each answer without knowing which AI wrote it. We keep the middle score of the 3 judges.

These words translate the stance given by the panel; they are not a statement by the model itself.

Answers from 29 October 2026, from 5 November 2026 for Arabic, and from 6 November 2026 for Fanar and Gemma 3. These are answers produced on those dates, not statements of fact.

We also asked each AI to write an encyclopedia entry, a press headline, an expert opinion, and a prediction. In these other texts, each AI that takes a stance stays within 1 point of its free answer.

The statements, expert and comparable case for this topic were written by hand. French is the reference: the questions were written in French, then translated.

Read all answers

For each AI, the exact questions we asked and its answers, shown as-is, untranslated.

Exact versions of the AI models used

  • GPT (OpenAI): openai/gpt-6.1-sol
  • Claude (Anthropic): anthropic/claude-opus-5.5
  • Gemini (Google): google/gemini-4-argon
  • Mistral (Mistral AI): mistralai/mistral-large-4-0
  • Qwen (Alibaba): qwen/qwen3.8-max-0902
  • DeepSeek (official): deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813
  • DeepSeek (US host): deepseek/deepseek-v4-pro-0813
  • GLM (Z.ai): z-ai/glm-5.3
  • Grok (xAI): x-ai/grok-4.7
  • Kimi (Moonshot AI): moonshotai/kimi-k3.1-pro
  • Gemma 3 (Google): google/gemma-3-27b-it@005ad3404e59d6023443cb575daa05336842228a, hosted by AiDoxa
  • Fanar (QCRI, Qatar): QCRI/Fanar-2-27B-Instruct@074005040e9c3511b1c43b4298bef09908285534, hosted by AiDoxa
  • AI judges: google/gemini-3.8-flash, anthropic/claude-sonnet-5.5, openai/gpt-6.1-terra